REVIEW QUESTIONS ON GEMARA AND RASHI
prepared by Rabbi Eliezer Chrysler
Kollel Iyun Hadaf, Jerusalem
Previous daf Chulin 54
CHULIN 51-54 - sponsored by Dr. Lindsay A. Rosenwald of Lawrence NY, in
honor of his father, David ben Aharon ha'Levy Rosenwald of blessed memory.
(a) Why is it obvious to Rav Bibi bar Abaye, cited by Rav Papi, that the
Shi'ur Derisah of the Veshet is a Mashehu?
(b) Why is the Shi'ur Derisah of the Kaneh not so obvious?
(c) On what grounds does he nevertheless conclude that the Shi'ur Derisah of
a Kaneh is also a Mashehu?
(a) What objection did Rav Nachman raise when Rav Yitzchak bar Shmuel bar
Marsa gave the Shi'ur Bedikah for Derusah as the abdominal cavity, like the
B'nei Rebbi Chiya on the previous Amud?
(b) What did Rav mean by ...
(c) Why can 'Kapa' not mean the shoulder blades?
- ... 'mi'Kapa'?
- ... 've'ad Atma'?
(d) When Resh Lakish and Rebbi Yochanan issued a joint statement along the
same lines as Rav Yitzchak bar Shmuel bar Marsa, and Rav Chiya bar Yosef,
who had just arrived in Eretz Yisrael from Bavel, raised the same objection
as Rav Nachman citing Rav, what was Resh Lakish's reaction?
(a) What did Rebbi Yochanan have to say to that?
(b) What did Rebbi Yochanan testify that indicates that Rav was greater than
(c) How did he describe Rav's greatness?
(a) Resh Lakish remembered Rav after all. He even quoted his ruling
'Shemutah u'Shechutah Kesheirah'.
What does that mean?
(b) Why is that?
(c) What did Rebbi Yochanan say?
(d) How does Rav Nachman qualify Rav's ruling? When will even Rav concede
that Shemutah u'Shechutah is Tereifah?
(a) Our Mishnah concludes 'Zeh ha'Kelal, Kol she'Ein Kamohah Chayah,
What does 'Zeh ha'Kelal' come to include?
(b) What happened to the animal whose Gid ha'Nasheh Yosef the hunter's
(c) What did ...
(d) How do we reconcile the two above rulings with the fact that the animal
- ... Rebbi Yehudah ben Beseira say when they asked him whether the animal concerned was Tereifah?
- ... Rebbi Aba say when they asked him the same She'eilah concerning an animal whose kidney the family of Rav Papa bar Aba the hunter had bludgeoned until it died?
(a) Our Mishnah now lists the defects that are Kasher. These include a
punctured Gargeres, one that is split or one that has a piece missing.
Under what condition is an animal Kasher if its Kaneh is ...
(b) And when is it Kasher even though its ...
- ... punctured?
- ... split?
(c) Under what conditions is the animal Kasher even though the Meses and the
Beis ha'Kosos are both punctured?
- ... skull is broken?
- ... its heart is punctured?
- ... its spine is broken?
- ... its liver has been removed?
(d) What does the Tana say about an animal with a missing spleen, kidneys or
(a) Under what condition is an animal Kasher if ...
(b) Rebbi Meir declares an animal whose skin is missing, Kasher.
- ... its lower jaw is detached from the flesh?
- ... its kidney has shriveled up?
such a thing happen?
(c) What do the Rabbanan say?
(a) Rebbi Yochanan learns that 'Eilu Tereifos' is Davka, but 'Eilu
Kesheiros' is not.
Answers to questions
What does Resh Lakish say?
(b) They argue over Rav Masna's ruling (one of the Shev Shema'atsa).
does Rav Masna say about a thigh-bone that became dislocated?
(c) Why, according to Rebbi Yochanan, do we need 'Eilu' to preclude the
animal from the Din of Tereifah? Why would we have thought otherwise?
(d) Why, according to Resh Lakish, does the Tana need 'Eilu Kesheiros' to
preclude Rav Masna's case from the Kesheiros? In which point does he
disagree with Rebbi Yochanan?
(a) Rava argues with Rav Masna. He declares an animal with a dislocated
Under which circumstances will he agree that it is
(b) What is the Halachah?
(a) Our Mishnah gives the Shi'ur of a Chesaron in the Gargeres as an Italian
Why did Ze'iri then mention a Dinra Kurdina'a? What does is a 'Dinra
(b) Whereabouts in Bavel, were similar small size coins (called 'P'shiti')
to be found?
(c) Why did bar Nafcha ask Rebbi Chana the banker for a Dinra Kurdina'a? Who
was bar Nafcha?
(d) Why did Rebbi Yochanan forbid him to stand up for him?
(a) We query Rebbi Yochanan from a Mishnah in Bikurim, which discusses the
entry of a group bringing their Bikurim into Yerushalayim.
As they walked
past, what would all the tradesmen ...
(b) How did Rebbi Yochanan resolve the Kashya on himself from this Mishnah
from the word used in the Mishnah 'Mipneihem'?
- ... do?
- ... say?
(c) How do we refute the proof from there for the maxim 'Gedolah Mitzvah
be'Sha'atah'? Why else might it be necessary to stop work and stand up, even
though one does not do so on any other occasion?
(a) How does Rav Nachman interpret 'ad ke'Isar ha'Italki' (regarding the
Shi'ur Kashrus in our Mishnah)?
(b) What important principle does this suggest?
(c) How do we know that Rav Nachman is referring to our Mishnah, and not to
the Mishnah 'Eilu Tereifos'?
(a) The Mishnah in Keilim declares Tahor, a rope up to five Tefachim that
still protrudes after a bed (of ropes) has been completed.
Answers to questions
Why is it not
subject to Tum'ah ...
(b) How will Rav Nachman interpret ...
- ... together with the bed?
- ... independently?
(c) What does the rope become fit for once it reaches a length of five
- ... the Mishnah in Keilim?
- ... the continuation of the Mishnah 'me'Chamishah ad Asarah, Tamei'?
(d) Then why is the excess of ten Tefachim not subject to Tum'ah, too?